Tobin Mitnick provided ample evidence of Taylor Swift’s thespian talents, sharing a Thursday Instagram thread with throwback photos. The actor and comedian revisited the period when Swift took on the role of Sandy Olsson in a local production of Grease.

Mitnick served as Swift’s co-star during that time, taking on the role of her love interest, Danny Zuko, a character originally portrayed by John Travolta in the ’70s musical comedy. Captioning the post, he expressed gratitude to his mom for retrieving pictures of their collaboration with Taylor Swift, harmonizing like “buttah” on summer nights a quarter-century ago, and pulling them out of storage.

Throwback photos of Taylor Swift as Sandy in a Grease production

Swifties were particularly captivated by the third picture, where the “Anti-Hero” singer rocked a voluminous wig with curly blonde locks, embodying the essence of her Grease lead character.

Concluding his caption, Tobin Mitnick playfully nodded to Taylor Swift’s current boyfriend, Travis Kelce, the tight end for the Kansas City Chiefs, stating, “Also, Trav, the note is an F-sharp if you’re interested. June 2000.” Tobin shared three snapshots of their younger selves in the post.

Fans react to the Taylor Swift Grease throwback photos

Mitnick’s carousel post has ignited a vibrant comments section as fans discover Taylor Swift’s connection to Grease. Reactions such as “I NEVER IN A MILLION YEARS SAW THIS CROSSOVER COMING,” “This is an insane crossover,” and “This was not the mashup I was expecting today” flooded the post, showcasing awestruck admiration.

Swifties took the opportunity to express their admiration for Taylor Swift, with comments like “This just further proves that Taylor had always been THAT girl… I can see why she is ruling major stages across the globe.” Meanwhile, some users couldn’t resist commenting on Taylor’s Sandy costume and wig, stating, “Ok but Taylor’s wig is cracking me up,” and another user humorously remarked, “Why wasn’t this part of the eras tour.” The comments reflect the unexpected delight of fans witnessing this unique connection to Taylor’s past.