‘Throw Us A Bone’: Indy The Star Dog Of Good Boy Appeals Academy For Oscars

​In a cinematic climate increasingly dominated by debates over “nepo babies” and their struggle to consistently deliver box office successes, an unexpected new star has emerged: Indy, the four-legged furry lead of the horror-thriller Good Boy. Indy’s performance has not only garnered critical acclaim but has also prompted his studio, the independent powerhouse IFC, to launch a groundbreaking and thoroughly charming awards campaign. This effort includes a heartfelt, yet hilarious, open letter, penned, supposedly, by Indy himself, addressed to the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences, making a passionate plea for the inclusion of animal actors in the Oscars’ competitive acting categories.

​The letter, distributed by IFC and obtained exclusively by Variety, argues that it is high time Hollywood acknowledged and rewarded the talent and emotional depth delivered by its non-human performers. “Despite my critically acclaimed role in the recent film ‘Good Boy,’ — I have been deemed ineligible for the Best Actor category,” Indy “laments” in the opening salvo. He then delivers the perfect, self-aware punchline: “Apparently, I am not a good enough boy for you.” This blend of genuine artistic frustration and playful dog-speak has made the letter an instant viral hit.

​Indy’s campaign cleverly leverages the long history of unforgettable animal performances that have deeply resonated with human audiences, proving that great acting transcends species. The letter highlights beloved animal stars such as Jed the wolf-dog in White Fang, the majestic whale in Free Willy, and the unforgettable pig, Babe, whose film helped secure a Best Picture nomination at the Oscars. Yet, as Indy points out in his persuasive argument, none of these legendary four-legged performers ever received the coveted golden statue they undeniably deserved. This historical oversight, Indy suggests, is an injustice that the Academy must correct.

​A “Paw-some” Plea and a Playful Jab at the Academy

​The letter’s central question cuts to the heart of the matter, challenging the Academy’s long-standing exclusionary rules: “How many great performances must go overlooked before the Academy throws us a bone?” This powerful query, delivered with perfect wordplay, encapsulates the campaign’s mission to recognize the skill, training, and emotional commitment required for an animal to successfully execute a complex cinematic role.

​Indy saves one of his best comedic moments for the closing remarks, where he takes a final, playful jab at the institution: “We ask that you stop lifting your leg on the contribution of myself and the many great animal actors whose work continues to go unrecognised.” This irresistible closing statement ensures the letter ends on a memorable and characteristically canine note, guaranteeing its continued circulation on social media.

​The internet, as expected, went immediately wild for Indy’s heartfelt campaign. Fans enthusiastically mobilized on platforms like X (formerly Twitter) to support the star’s cause. “Pls give him his award :(” pleaded one fan, while another noted, “He understood the assignment and sat for it.” The witty comments flowed freely: “A good boy being denied a treat breaks my soul,” lamented one user, and another quipped that the category should be renamed “Best Boy.” Perhaps the most accurate and endearing tribute came from a fan who declared, “The only actor who actually deserves a standing ovation and a belly rub.”

​Bringing Joy to a Serious Awards Season

​Beyond the humor and the viral attention, the campaign raises a valid question about the formal recognition of animal actors, whose performances—often requiring rigorous training and precise execution—are integral to the success of many films. While the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences currently provides no dedicated category for non-human performers, Indy’s charming petition has forced the industry to think, however lightly, about the parameters of “acting” itself.

​Whether this genuinely “paw-some” campaign will lead to any material changes within the Academy’s rules remains highly unlikely in the short term. However, at a time when awards season conversations can often feel overly serious and politically charged, Indy’s open letter and the massive fan reaction it has generated have injected a much-needed dose of joy, humour, and universally relatable warmth. The campaign successfully proves that sometimes, the best method for making a serious point is simply to have a “Good Boy” ask for the treat he deserves.