The political drama web series ‘Maharani,’ starring Huma Qureshi, faced controversy when it came to light that the show had filmed certain scenes within the Jammu and Kashmir assembly complex. The decision has sparked outrage from several quarters, raising questions about the sanctity of democratic institutions and the appropriateness of using them as film sets.
The Controversy Erupts
The controversy erupted in January 2024 when Omar Abdullah, the previous chief minister of Jammu & Kashmir, adopted social media to express his disapproval of the filming. He called it an “absolute shame” and questioned the decision to allow the assembly complex, a symbol of democracy, to be a backdrop for a fictional drama.
The true face of “the mother of democracy”, where once elected representatives of the people from all parties, religions, backgrounds & parts of J&K legislated on matters of great importance now actors & extras use it as a set for TV dramas. What a shame that the BJP driven… pic.twitter.com/kukyD0cQgt
— Omar Abdullah (@OmarAbdullah) January 12, 2024
Several other politicians and members of the civil society echoed Abdullah’s criticism. They argued that filming within the assembly complex undermines its dignity and sets a dangerous precedent. People also raised concerns about the potential commercial misuse of such sensitive spaces.
The Defense
The makers of Maharani have defended their decision, claiming that they obtained all necessary permissions from the relevant authorities before filming. They also argued that the show portrays the assembly complex positively and highlights the importance of democratic institutions.
Filmmaker Hansal Mehta, known for his socially conscious films, also came out supporting the Maharani team. He criticized the “regressive” attitude of those who oppose filming in such spaces and argued that it discourages filmmakers and harms India’s reputation as a shooting location.
Why is it a shame? How is filming of a drama demeaning democracy or the ‘mother of democracy’? Every body on a film set including actors, background actors(called ‘extras’ by you) are all citizens of this country and have every right to work with dignity and deserve respect and… https://t.co/JlvalzhhU1
— Hansal Mehta (@mehtahansal) January 12, 2024
The Debate Continues
The controversy surrounding Maharani has sparked a broader discussion of the functions of television and movies in shaping public perception of political institutions. While some argue that such depictions can be educational and informative, others worry about the potential for trivialization and sensationalize.
The discussion will probably continue in the days ahead, with no easy answers. Ultimately, it is up to the public and policymakers to decide whether or not filming within sensitive spaces like the Jammu and Kashmir assembly complex is acceptable.